Surely
everyone has heard one horror story or another about the services rendered
inside of Veterans Administration Hospitals.
Anyone remembering the scenes from Oliver Stone's movie Born on the Fourth of July where Tom Cruise’s character, Ron Kovic,
lays unattended for hours screaming for help can sympathize with the gentleman
I’m about to introduce you to.
Meet
Lynn Carter, a US Navy veteran from Fort Smith, Arkansas who has served his
nation honorably. He is one of many
examples of veterans across this nation who has earned and deserves our utmost
respect. It is, after all, the service of Lynn and veterans like him that
ensures the freedom and prosperity that America has enjoyed throughout our
nation’s history. Yet respect has eluded
Mr. Carter and his wife Kathleen for nearly a year now.
In
June of 2011 Lynn was visiting a VA eye clinic in Fayetteville, Arkansas when
he began to suffer from an intense headache and his blood pressure went sky
high. Having suffered a stroke in May of
2011, the eye doctor at the VA clinic suggested Lynn go immediately to the VA
Hospital Emergency Room, also in Fayetteville.
After
Lynn arrived at the emergency room, VA medical staff conducted an MRI of his brain
and had to send the results to a doctor in Alabama. Apparently there was not enough staff on hand
in Fayetteville to evaluate the results.
As it turns out, Lynn had suffered another stroke while at the eye
clinic. This is only where his horror
story of begins.
For
nearly five hours Lynn laid waiting on a gurney in the hallway of the VA
Hospital. He was accompanied by his wife
and numerous other veterans who had suffered various illnesses and injuries
warranting an emergency room visit. For five
hours Lynn laid there waiting for word on his MRI, blood thinning medication
such as he received from his hometown hospital after his previous stroke, or for
someone to simply ask if he was doing alright.
Lynn describes the scene as a “humiliating disgrace” where veterans were
parked “on gurneys in hallways and anywhere else they could stick them.” According to Lynn the VA staff conceded simply
“that they were short staffed and did not have the personnel to take care of
everyone in a timely manner.”
Had
someone bothered to ask Lynn how he was doing during that five hour wait he
would have surely told them that he had urinated on himself or that he recognized
the symptoms of stroke which he had suffered only a month prior. They would have heard from Lynn’s own mouth
that he would like to have dry sheets and clothes to wear while he laid waiting
on news and/or medication to help ease his suffering. None of that happened however. Instead Lynn’s wife Kathleen eventually demanded
that he be released so that she could take Lynn back to Fort Smith to receive the
help from their local hospital that he was being denied at the VA. The VA claims Lynn was discharged from the VA
Hospital against the medical advice of the doctors working that day, after the
Carters demanded to go to their hometown Hospital.
After
all of this the Carters did not know who to turn to. They knew they had been
done wrong but didn’t know how to remedy the problem so they began to write to various
members of congress for assistance and specifically their own US Representative,
Steve Womack. After all isn’t the job of
our representatives in Washington DC to “represent” our interests as it
pertains to US Government?
Recently I posted on www.theprogressivecop.com a page
long response from Representative Womack in response to The Progressive Cop contributing writer Innocence Jaded’s request
that Womack denounce Rush Limbaugh over the Sandra Fluke comments. In sharp contrast to that response about an
issue that effects Womack’s constituents indirectly at best, the Carters received
a simple six line response in which Womack politely tells them he can’t do
anything for them.
After receiving no help
from Congressman Womack, Lynn began trying to call the offices of both Representative
Womack and Senator Mark Pryor but was unable to speak with either of them. He
eventually wrote a very blunt letter to both of them asking why they refused to
answer his phone calls. Lynn had some
very simple requests, among them was to know why his complaint was not further
investigated.
Lynn goes on in his fiery
letter to the Congressmen, to say that his grandson could have gotten better
results. Reflecting on the letter to
Congressman Womack seeking condemnation of Rush Limbaugh and the prompt and
lengthy response we received compared to the response given Lynn’s complaint, I
would agree that Mr. Carter’s grandson could have gotten better results from
Mr. Womack.
What the Carters want
is not monetary compensation but a simple apology and some assurance that
efforts will be made to ensure that other veterans won’t be treated the same
way in the future. Taking into
consideration that Congressman Womack recently voted for the Ryan Budget
proposed by Congressman Paul Ryan of Wisconsin, it does not appear that fixing
the problems over at the Veterans Administration is too high on Womack’s list
of things to do. After all, Ryan’s
budget proposal fails to mention the word “veteran” even once while somehow
cutting an estimated $11 billion in funding for veterans. This means that if Congressmen Ryan and
Womack have their way, there will be even less staff on hand to assist veterans
like Lynn if there even remains a VA Hospital within a day’s drive of Lynn’s
house.
Currently the United
States accounts for what is estimated to be between 42 to 46% of global
military spending. That is six to seven
times higher than the next biggest spender China. Together with our NATO Allies we account for roughly
three quarters of global military spending.
Given that fact, it is hard to argue that the West could be seriously
threatened by anyone of terrestrial origin.
At a time when both
parties acknowledge our national budget is in peril and it is universally recognized
that the balance of revenues and spending are out of whack, doesn’t it make
sense to cut some of that military spending rather than cutting promises made
to those who have risked everything for our freedom? Congressmen such as Ryan and Womack are
simply too concerned with keeping the tax rates of the richest one percent and
the bottom lines of defense contractors and oil companies healthy at the
expense of hardworking Americans and veterans like Lynn Carter. It is high time we let Congressmen like Ryan
and Womack know they represent us, the people, and not the almighty dollar.
.jpg)
This is despicable and degrading, and I'm sorry that someone who served our country can't be served in return. People first!
ReplyDeleteFirst of all, the real and abiding issue here is the horrendous state of treatment at the VA hospitals. It's unnecessary and inhumane. But I do have a few specific questions and comments and suggestions.
ReplyDelete1. What exactly did Mr. Carter ask of Womack's office? To investigate his specific situation, or the procedures of that hospital in general? Is there a claim of medical misconduct being made (in other words, if this was a civilian hospital, would he be contacting a lawyer about suing?) Did Mr. Carter contact the rep's local office in Arkansas, or the one in DC? (Big difference.)
2. Did Mr. Carter contact any members (esp. Democrats) of the Veterans Affairs Committee? If you're talking about general complaints, and the lack of accountability and its very real, human cost, this would be the place to go. I would mention, however, that you did already contact your own rep who could not help. Send them any copies of documentation you can.
3.He should also detail all of this and send it to the Solicitor General (or IG?) in charge of the VA system. I'm not sure which agency it would be; you could probably search for some newspaper investigative reports and find that out. If there is medical misconduct, this is the place to go.
4. Has he gone to the local (non-Fox) media?
While I'll be the first to guess that Womack is probably a tool, and his staff should have recognized a constituent who feels essentially raped and violated by a system over which he has no control and sent a more personal letter, you should realize that unless there is a specific grievance to be redressed, or an incident of medical misconduct is being alleged, there probably isn't anything a member's constituent services staff can do.
Although maybe someone could have taken 5 minutes like I did to give some suggestions or find out more information. But I guess the GOP staffers these days are too busy making up numbers for Paul Ryan's budget to actually help people even that little.
lol, is there such a thing as non-fox media in are near Fort Smith Arkansas?
DeleteMr. Carter,
DeleteI am pleased to see you here. I hope that I have done your story justice. I hope that we are able to increase awareness about the events surrounding your June 2011 visit and the run around you have been given every since.
As a fellow veteran, I would like to thank you for your service. I want to let you know that you have a lot of brothers and sisters out here who will help ensure your voice is heard.
The Progressive Cop
I believe the last two paragraphs of your comment sum up what Mr. Carter was looking for and did not receive from Womack's office. Furthermore, I do not feel that the VA is necessarily the problem here.
ReplyDeleteI feel that inadequate funding which Ryan and Womack threaten to make even more scarce, is the crux of the problem. Mr. Carter was forced to wait for so long because the doctor evaluating his MRI wasn two states away. His stay was made less than comfortable because, as the VA admitted, they were understaffed and therefore could not provide the necessary care for all of the patients that evening.
The politics of the budget aside, why couldn't Womack or one of his staffers taken the time to give Mr. Carter some simple suggestions such as yours? The answer, I suspect, has more to do with a Congressman who cares more about political posturing in DC and serving the constituents nearest and dearest to his heart: Wal-Mart, Arvest Bank, Tyson Foods, and Koch Brothers Industries to name just four of his top five donors.
If Mr. Carter had made that elite list, mountains would have been moved for him by Womack.
I think the general issue that is more pressing, if there is a more pressing issue than Veteran care, is the fact that so many of our elected officials are either motivated by moving forward towards the power, or making money. Neither of which serves their constituents. They seem to forget that these are what were once considered service positions. We need people to serve our interest and not their own.
ReplyDeleteThe most disgusting thing in this entire situation is the above mentioned politicians always have the nerve to stand before us and say that their constituents are the most important people to them - when in fact, the most important thing to them are their money, greed and power hungry ways. And its proven true over and over again day in and day out. Its awfully funny that Womack cannot help his constituents - but he can sure get his son out of drug charges time and time again...and the media shuts up about it - just like he tells them to do.........at least the ones in his back pocket!!!!!!!!! Thanks for your help, Mr. Womack!!!
ReplyDeleteKitty Carter
Caregiver of Lynn Carter
My heart goes out to Mr. Carter and I am so glad that this story has been brought to light. From one vet to another thank you for your service as well. People First!!
ReplyDelete